MaNaDr Clinic, located at City Gate along Beach Road, has been ordered to cease its outpatient telemedicine services effective Friday, 16 August 2024.
This order follows Singapore’s Ministry of Health (MOH) investigation. It uncovered troubling practices, including extremely brief teleconsultations and the issuance of multiple medical certificates (MCs) within short periods.
Short Consultations Raise Red Flags
During the investigation, MOH discovered that MaNaDr Clinic conducted over 100,000 teleconsultations in a single sampled month. Many of these consultations lasted one minute or less. In one alarming case, a teleconsultation was recorded at just one second. Such brief consultations have raised significant concerns regarding the quality and safety of patient care.
“Short consultations of this nature are highly concerning, particularly when it comes to ensuring the quality of clinical care,” MOH stated in a press release. The ministry emphasised that telemedicine services must uphold the same standards of care as in-person consultations.
Multiple MCs Issued Over Short Periods
In addition to the unusually brief consultations, the investigation revealed that some patients were issued multiple MCs within short timeframes. In one instance, a single patient received 19 MCs in one month. Over 1,500 patients were given MCs on five or more occasions during the same period.
These findings have prompted questions about the clinic’s practices. Consequently, MOH expressed concerns that such actions may compromise patient care and lead to potential misuse of telemedicine services.
Detailed Case Notes Questioned
Interestingly, despite the short duration of many consultations, some case notes appeared unusually detailed, containing information that did not align with the brief interaction times. Conversely, other case notes were extremely sparse, potentially jeopardising the continuity of patient care.
MOH noted that such discrepancies could suggest that the clinic was not following proper telemedicine protocols, requiring thorough patient interaction documentation.
Ongoing Investigation and Potential Disciplinary Action
MOH’s investigation into MaNaDr Clinic is ongoing. The ministry has clarified that it will take further enforcement action if necessary. It is currently reviewing the clinical consultations of the medical practitioners involved. Should there be any breaches of the Singapore Medical Council’s (SMC) ethical code and guidelines, the practitioners will be referred to the SMC for disciplinary measures.
The ministry has also stated that it will audit and monitor other licensed providers of outpatient telemedicine services, particularly those operating on platforms similar to MaNaDr.
Broader Implications for Telemedicine Providers
The suspension of MaNaDr Clinic’s telemedicine services highlights the broader concerns surrounding the growing use of telemedicine in Singapore. As more healthcare providers offer remote consultations, ensuring that these services meet the required standards of care is paramount.
MOH has reiterated the importance of compliance with the Healthcare Services Act and the relevant licensing conditions for remote outpatient medical services. The ministry has reminded all telemedicine medical practitioners to adhere to the SMC’s ethical code and guidelines.
Conclusion
The suspension of MaNaDr Clinic’s telemedicine services reminds us that while telemedicine offers convenience and accessibility, it must not compromise the quality of patient care. MOH’s ongoing investigation will likely result in further scrutiny of telemedicine practices across Singapore, ensuring that all providers maintain the highest standards of clinical care.
As telemedicine evolves, the healthcare community must, therefore, remain vigilant to safeguard patient health and safety.
Have a pressing question for a doctor? Medical Channel Asia has launched a community forum page where you can get questions answered by a medical specialist. Visit the community forum here.
